Life in the little Apple: Chinese family reveal tiny apartment life in New York with five crammed into a 350-sq-ft space in search of American dream

纽约惊现中国式袖珍公寓,为寻美国梦一家5口硬挤350平方英尺
Myriah Towner For Dailymail.com

Photographer Thomas Holton has documented the life of Steven and Shirley Lam and their three children.[CN]

摄影师汤马斯·霍顿记录了史蒂芬一家五口(包括老婆和3个孩子)的生活。

The photos reflect their every day lives in cramped quarters of an apartment in a tenement building on Ludlow Street.[CN]

照片反映了他们蜗居在洛德勒街狭窄住房的日常。

The work started in 2003 as a documentary project for his master's thesis and 13 years later it has become a book.[CN]

摄影工作始于2003年,应霍顿提出打造纪录片之需。13年后,纪录片被编撰成书。

Holton feels his work has resonated with so many  because people feel they can relate to the story about life and 'making the best with what you have'[CN]

霍顿觉得作品引起了广泛的共鸣。人们从故事中发现了生活智慧:物尽其用。

3373861100000578-3554132-image-a-2_1461361867446.jpg

Photographer Thomas Holton has documented the life of a Chinese family living inside a 350 square-foot apartment in New York City's Chinatown neighborhood with poignant images spanning a decade. The three Lam children, Michael, Franklin and Cindy pictured in 2003.[CN]

霍顿记录的中国家庭,住在纽约市唐人街隔壁的350平方英尺的屋子。唐人街也是经历了一个年代的心酸历程。图为拉姆的三个孩子:迈克尔,富兰克林,辛迪。

3373853C00000578-3554132-image-a-35_1461365529594.jpg

The Lam children pictured during bath time in 2004. In 2003, Holton was with a local housing advocate when he met Steven and Shirley Lam and their three New-York born children who lived in a fifth-floor apartment in a tenement building on Ludlow Street.[CN]

图片摄于2004年,拉姆的孩子们在共同沐浴。03年时,霍顿认识了史蒂芬,雪莉·拉姆和他们在纽约出生的三个孩子。当时他们住在洛德勒街出租房的5楼,霍顿则和当地一个住房政策拥趸者住在一起。

3373856000000578-3554132-image-a-4_1461363089470.jpg

Ms Lam prepares food while watching a Chinese soap opera in 2004. Holton, born to a Chinese mother and an American father, had started photographing the streets and daily rituals of Chinatown in an effort to better understand his own Chinese heritage.[CN]

图为2004年的拉姆边看中国肥皂剧边做饭。霍顿的母亲是中国人,父亲是美国人,因而他从小就开始拍摄唐人街的街景和各种日常礼仪,试图更好的了解自己的中国血统。

3373854400000578-3554132-image-a-33_1461365515947.jpg

The Lams captured in a family portrait before having a meal in 2004. Holton's project started as a traditional documentary project for his master's thesis but turned more intimate as he began an in-depth photographic look at the family's every day life in the cramped quarters

3373853800000578-3554132-image-a-38_1461365555457.jpg

The family's laundry dries on a clothes line on the roof of their building with views of New York City in the background in 2004

3373855400000578-3554132-image-a-6_1461363122719.jpg

Mr Lam seen above with sons Michael and Franklin in 2005. During Holton's time photographing the family, Mr Lam and Ms Lam end up divorcing

337385FE00000578-3554132-image-a-7_1461363132290.jpg

The Lams' front door of their apartment is pictured in 2005. Now 13 years later since he started the project in 2003, Holton's work has become a book, The Lams of Ludlow Street , published this month

3373854D00000578-3554132-image-a-10_1461363145425.jpg

A bouquet of flowers sit in the bathtub in a 2005 photo. Initially when Holton started the project, the 46-year-old was intrigued by the Tetris-like arrangement of the furniture inside the Lams' apartment (pictured) along with their daily routine

3373861D00000578-3554132-image-a-12_1461363162082.jpg

A bedroom in the apartment pictured in 2005. In his project's early work, Holton explores the family's surroundings and daily lives. At the time, Mr Lam worked at an import-export company while Ms Lam was a stay-at-home mother

3373856F00000578-3554132-image-a-14_1461363183215.jpg

Ms Lam takes a break and drinks from a bowl while sitting at a table in 2010. When he started the project Holton said he was excited to have the opportunity to get through 'the proverbial closed door and meet a neighborhood family who welcomed me into their lives'

3373860D00000578-3554132-image-a-16_1461363206887.jpg

Cindy lies next to her mother on the bed while her brother Franklin sits nearby and plays a game on the computer during Spring Break in 2010

3373853200000578-3554132-image-a-18_1461363226407.jpg

Cindy is pictured lying in bed while a curtain separates her from her brother who is doing work as they wait for dinner in 2011

3373861900000578-3554132-image-a-20_1461363248374.jpg

Cindy and Mr Lam relax on a bed inside their apartment while one of her brothers plays a game on a laptop, right, in 2012

3373862100000578-3554132-image-a-32_1461363356134.jpg

Cindy and her brother Michael, lounging on a bed and a couch, are pictured five days before he heads off for college in 2014

3373861500000578-3554132-image-a-29_1461363341922.jpg

Ms Lam sits on a bed while Cindy lays next to her and one of her sons does work. Meanwhile Mr Lam is seen giving a stern lecture to their other son, right, in 2014

3373852800000578-3554132-image-a-21_1461363283052.jpg

Cindy is pictured in 2014 checking her phone while waiting in the hallway of the apartment building

3373860900000578-3554132-image-a-28_1461363326512.jpg

Cindy and her brother are pictured in their father's new apartment in New Jersey in 2014. Holton said Cindy was 'amazed' by her father's walk-in closet as their Ludlow Street apartment did not have one

3373855C00000578-3554132-image-a-24_1461363297372.jpg

The oldest child, Michael, is pictured in his college dorm room for orientation at the State University of New York, Binghamton in 2014

3373860400000578-3554132-image-a-26_1461363309350.jpg

Cindy lounges after coming home from school as a piano sits below her bed in a 2015 photo taken by Holton

A photographer has documented the life of a Chinese family living inside a 350 square-foot apartment in New York City's Chinatown with poignant images spanning a decade.

In 2003, Thomas Holton was with a local housing advocate when he met Steven and Shirley Lam and their three New-York born children Michael, Franklin and Cindy. The family lived in a fifth-floor apartment in a tenement building on Ludlow Street, according to the New York Times.

At the time Holton, born to a Chinese mother and an American father, had started photographing the streets and daily rituals of Chinatown in an effort to better understand his own Chinese heritage.

But what started as a traditional documentary project for his master's thesis at the School of Visual Arts quickly turned more intimate as he began an in-depth photographic look at the Lams' every day life in the cramped quarters.

Now 13 years later, Holton's work has become a book, The Lams of Ludlow Street, published this month by Kehrer Verlag.

Initially when he started the project, the 46-year-old was intrigued by the Tetris-like arrangement of the furniture inside the Lams' apartment along with their daily routine, according to The New York Times. 

He was also excited to have the opportunity to get through 'the proverbial closed door and meet a neighborhood family who welcomed me into their lives,' Slate reported.

In his project's early work, it explores the family's surroundings and daily lives. At the time, Mr Lam worked at an import-export company while Ms Lam was a stay-at-home mother.

As he got to know the family - picking up the children from school, sharing meals, visiting their relatives in Hong Kong and China, and even having Cindy as his flower girl when he married - the project became more personal and evolved into exploring their family dynamics.

'Once this more intimate and personal aspect of our relationship developed, I became less and less interested in their small apartment and became much more curious about their family life, the relationships with one another and what was happening in their lives,' Holton told Slate.

'As a result, my images changed too - I feel they became much more nuanced and subtle.'

Holton, a now a parent himself, would take 'creative pauses' that would last a year or more and allowed the family's story to evolve, simultaneously informing the editing process for what has now become The Lams of Ludlow.

When Holton returned in 2010 to photograph the family, the family had changed and the photographs reflected their changing situation. 

The bed the children had shared as kids had been replaced by bunk beds and Ms Lam spent most of her time outside the apartment after becoming a home health aide, the New York Times reported.

'Chapter Two was very turbulent,' Holton told The Times. 'The parents were bickering. The kids were teenagers.'

Holton's latest series depicts the calm after the 'turbulent' season for the family, showing the oldest son Michael at college and his life in New York.

Mr and Ms Lam ended up divorcing with Mr Lam now living in New Jersey, according to The Times.

In one of Holton's photographs it shows Cindy, now 15, looking inside her father's walk-in closet as  their Ludlow Street apartment did not have a closet. Holton told the newspaper 'she was amazed.'

While Holton found himself becoming a 'strange uncle who always has a camera' to the Lams, he never was able to make the same connection with the Chinatown neighborhood, noting he is still considered an outsider or visitor because he does not live there or speak fluent Chinese, according to Slate.

Holton, who teaches photography at Trinity School in Manhattan, said he feels his work has resonated with so many because people feel they can relate to the story about life and 'making the best with what you have.'

国外网友评论 0人跟帖    8540人参与

Catherine

And I'll bet they're working hard, studying hard and one day, they will be our doctor, or lawyer, or employer. Good for them.

我敢断定,他们会好好学习,好好工作,终有一天成为我们的医生,律师或职工。好样的!

[ 1 ] [ 0 ]
Sleepless

They all look clean and healthy. I'd be willing to bet all of the children do well in school and improve their surroundings as adults.

他们衣衫整洁,生活健康。他们在校肯定名列前茅,像大人一样改变自己的周围环境。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
EricCc

Wish them luck but honestly they probably don't need it. I'd bet the kids will turn out to be very successful, hard working people who don't make excuses.

祝他们好运,事实上他们又何需我的祈祷呢?这些孩子会取得成功,成为不找借口,辛勤工作的人。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Sam777

If I was struggling financially, and had a family to support, I would not settle in one of the most expensive cities in America. But that's me.

我若果生活拮据,还得养家糊口,我不会再美国最贵的城市定居,这就是我啊。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
PattiT

Admirable that they came to this country legally, and have so far sent two of their children to college..

羡慕他们合法移民到这个国度,目前给2个小孩供了大学。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Mary Anne Farley

Even before I read the story, I made a bet with myself that all three of these kids will be going to college and will be productive and law abiding Americans. When Iwas a kid living in Toronto in the 50's, I saw people like them coming to Canada after the war from Poland, Czechoslovakia, The Ukraine etc. and how they hadnothing when they arrived after coming from war torn Europe but their kids went to school! It was such a good experience for a teen ager like myself to see such a work ethic and the experience definitely had a profound effect on me to this day.

没读完故事前,我就相信这三个孩子会考上大学,成为富有创造力,遵纪守法的美国公民。50年我还小住在多伦多,看到过很多人波兰人,捷克人,乌克兰人等因避免战争来到加拿大。他们从战火荼毒的欧洲土壤来,一无所有,但孩子却上了学。少年时代有幸看到这种职业精神,至今仍对我人生产生了重大影响。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Lauralove

Alot of people are mentioning that they aren't on welfare or are getting "government handouts". These are healthy people..... they aren't disabled (from what I can see)....... why would they?

很多人说,他们没有福利,也没收到政府津贴。我说看到的是,他们身体健康,有手有脚...他们怎么会稀罕呢?

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Walk

All leave their country for the West, and want Buckingham palace when they land in the west, my family are Indians from East Africa and worked hard to get into a life where I can have decent home, it takes time

所有背井离乡到西方打拼的人,都希望他们能在西方出人头地。我家人本是东非的印第安人,经过辛苦劳作在这边立住脚跟,让我有了真正的家,这需要时间啊。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
LuluLReply toWalk

True..sometimes generations.

没错,有时需要几代人的努力。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
liz in LAReply toWalk

It also takes determination and faith. Good luck.

也需要决心和信息,好运!

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
SommReply toWalk

Didn't get the impression that this family expected Buckingham Palace, rather that they, like your family, worked hard with what they had in the hope of better life for their children.

别以为这家人只想过白金汉宫式的生活,他们跟你的家庭一样,辛勤工作,尽力而为为孩子创造更好的生活。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
annop123Reply toWalk

Gross. They are trying hard. They never once ask for anything in this article. All I can see is a hard working family making it work...you're gross and apparently see something else.

恶心。他们努力工作,从不要求什么。我目所能及,是勤奋劳作的家庭取得了成功。你很恶心,曲解了原意。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
JimBReply toWalk

Actually, the hardworking don't expect much and they make sacrifices to provide for the next generation. That's why you see many generations living together, and none are on welfare.

实际上,他们辛苦劳作不求回报,牺牲自我,造福下一辈。这就是你看到多代人住在一起却不接受救济的原因了。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
PingeroReply toWalk

Think they've managed. Like many Chinese they will work hard and do what's possible for the children to contribute to society on another lever from their parents.

想着他们熬过来了。和大多数中国人一样,他们辛苦劳作,接过父母的杠杆,为孩子倾尽一切,造福社会。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
ParadeReply toWalk

No, they don't all want that.

不,并非所有人都追求出人头地。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
JoReply toWalk

How did they get a green card with all those kids.

他们孩子是怎么拿到绿卡的?

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
CarolineReply toWalk

The secret is don't move to a city where it's too expensive to live.

秘诀是不要搬到生活成本太高的城市。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
MailBoxer

Why do we have to assume that people who have ao little are unhappy? They have a roof over their heads ans a beautiful family. I know wealthy people who are miserable.

我们为什么要假想人们拥有的少就会闷闷不乐呢?他们有房子,有美好的家人陪伴就够了。富人有够可怜的。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
FalkirkReply toMailBoxer

The stress of that cramped lifestyle caused their divorce!

蜗居模式最终会导致他们离婚的!

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
SleeplessReply toMailBoxer

I think that if you feel you are making progress, you can be happy with very little. If you feel you are powerless to improve the situation for yourself and especially your children, you are much more likely to be unhappy.

我觉得每天进步一点点,你就会开心一点点。如果你无力改变当前的处境,尤其是无法为你孩子改善处境,才会闷闷不乐。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
MM

Sweet pictures - brilliant to see the son in his dorm room at college - this is a great he's working family. The way the laundry is done is smart with the hangers over the bath, in going to copy. I live in a one bed in Manhattan with my partner and child, the apartment has been in my husband's family generations - we're tied here namely because my son gets superior autism services and schooling in Manhattan.

好暖心的照片。能看到他儿子读大学的寝室太好了。他来自工人家庭。他洗衣方式很是精巧,衣架挂在浴盆边,我得学习学习。我在曼哈顿和父母孩子睡一张床,房子是丈夫家世代相传。我们苦苦撑着是因为我们孩子可以在曼哈顿接受更好的自闭症治疗和教育。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
CHILENA 1

it look no different from China's way, it look a Chinese family house only difference there are three kids instead of only one

与中国生活方式无异。唯一不同,中国家庭养一个孩子,这里是养三个。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Nun__Ya

People can do a lot with a little.

小处也可有大用。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
markhately - Ex-Pat

So tell me why this is supposed to be interesting...? It looks just like how 99% of China live. And why try and make it in New York, it's one of the most expensive cities in the world.

告诉我这哪里有趣了?看起来99%像足了中国生活方式。在纽约试试看,世界上最高生活成本城市之一。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
LemonsAPlenty

Looks exactly like how they live in China.

跟中国生活模式一模一样!

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Scorp098

It's amazing what people will risk to live their dream, it is the same in the UK, immigrants are sometimes the hardest of workers and the most passionate. Good luck to them

惊奇的是人们可以冒很大险来实现自己的梦想。在英国也一样,移民有时是最勤奋最有激情的。好运!

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
HesSpartacuSReply toScorp098

Sometimes? All immigrants should be hard workers. The reason why there's 1000's of immigrants in Calais wanting to come to England is because of our benefit system. If they really wanted to work they'd stay in France.

有时候而已?所有移民都是努力工作的人。法国加赖有1000移民想去英国是因为福利制度。真想工作的话,他们留在法国就可以了。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
pg58

These people come there and, in less than a generation, are doing better than many families who've been here for generations. I have no doubt their children will be successful, as they have sown a willingness to sacrifice and to help each other. I applaud them.[CN]

这些人来了,用不到一代人的努力,就超过了很多家庭几代的成绩。他们孩子的成功是必然的,因为他们很早就学会了甘愿奉献,乐于助人的品质、为他们鼓掌。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Bela Rafti
I find this bizarre in the sense that they could have secured 4-5 times the square footage in queens and still had access to public transportation. I definitely understand the need in the short term to settle for subpar housing but there are questions here that aren't being answered. Chinatown really isn't a desirable location and there are many other large asian communities throughout the boroughs.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Sarah the nurseReply toBela Rafti
Maybe they have bad credit? No credit? Applying for an apartment lease these days can be as bad as applying for a mortgage. Perhaps they rented from the only landlord who would rent to them.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Sandy BeachesReply toBela Rafti
Ever work for wages Bela. If not, perhaps you don't know that some make very little money & this is the best they can afford.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Lee00enderReply toBela Rafti
Please tell me which part of Queens we can secure 4-5 times the square footage mentioned in this article (along with access to public transportation), and likewise, is affordable to low income people like us. I can certainly use such a place right now with my family currently living in cramped conditions in Flushing, Queens. It is and will always be a pipe dream to have a much larger place to live in NYC unless we are earning hundreds of thousands and above.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
mruptightReply toBela Rafti
They could easily be paying less that a grand for chinatown due to rent control. Queens is not a match.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
mruptightReply toBela Rafti
They could easily be paying less than a grand for a rent-controlled apartment. I knew someone paying $400 there 10 years ago. Queens is reaching Manhattan prices.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Dee
There is no longer an American Dream. When you get it there is always someone trying to take it away. It's a constant struggle. TRUTH.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
GalaticamanReply toDee
It's not true.Immigrants still manage to succeed.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
LadyGrey22Reply toDee
what you don't realize is that "the american dream" itself is a fallacy.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Macy
Wow, and they still eat way better than me in my big old house. Puts things into perspective, doesn't it?
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
JaySon0747
People make choices. They chose to live like that. America is not just NYC. You can move anywhere without government approval.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]

评论

游客 请登录 注册